Blog / Secondhand Treasures: Discover Key West’s Thrift Shops

Secondhand Treasures: Discover Key West’s Thrift Shops

Posted: Mar. 06, 2025

Thrift shops in Key West FL are treasure troves filled with secondhand wonders waiting to be finded. Here, the charm of the island meets the thrill of the hunt for unique finds. Whether you’re searching for vintage clothing, eclectic souvenirs, or distinctive antiques, Key West offers a vibrant shopping experience perfect for both seasoned thrifters and curious newcomers.

Quick Picks for Top Thrift Shops:

  • Kirby’s Closet: Known for delightful clothing finds and a welcoming atmosphere.
  • Salvation Army on Flagler: Great for souvenirs and budget-friendly items.
  • French Kiss and The Green Pineapple: For those seeking vintage and repurposed gems.
  • In One Era and Island Antiques: Perfect for antique lovers.
  • St. Peter’s Thrift Shop: A local favorite with interesting inventory.


As Chris Higgins, an artist with a flair for unique designs, I’ve spent over a decade absorbing Key West’s creative energy, and its thrift shops never cease to inspire. Now, let’s dive deeper into the secondhand treasures that await you on this captivating island.

Top Thrift Shops in Key West

When it comes to thrift shops in Key West FL, each store offers its own unique blend of character and charm. Here’s a closer look at some of the top spots to explore:


Second Time Around

Second Time Around is a beloved local spot known for its eclectic collection of gently used clothing and accessories. Here, you can find everything from casual wear to chic, vintage pieces that add a touch of uniqueness to your wardrobe. The store is well-organized, making the thrifting experience both enjoyable and rewarding.

Salvation Army Family Store

The Salvation Army Family Store on Flagler Avenue is a staple in Key West’s thrift scene. Known for its wide range of affordable items, this store is a great place to find souvenirs and everyday essentials. It’s especially popular among budget-conscious shoppers seeking quality goods at a fraction of the price.

The Shore Store

For those who love a mix of modern and retro, The Shore Store is a must-visit. This shop offers a variety of items that reflect the laid-back, coastal vibe of Key West. From beachwear to quirky home décor, there’s always something interesting to find here.

Blue Marlin

Blue Marlin stands out for its selection of vintage clothing and nautical-themed treasures. This thrift shop is perfect for those looking to accept the maritime spirit of Key West. With a keen eye, you might find a unique piece that tells its own story of the sea.

Happy Island

Happy Island brings a cheerful twist to the thrift shopping experience. This store is known for its vibrant atmosphere and diverse inventory, which includes everything from colorful clothing to one-of-a-kind souvenirs. It’s a place where shoppers can truly accept the joy of finding hidden gems.

Each of these stores contributes to the rich mix of thrift shops in Key West FL. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, exploring these shops is a delightful way to uncover the island’s hidden treasures. Next, let’s explore the unique finds and vintage gems that make Key West’s thrift scene so special.

Unique Finds and Vintage Gems

Key West is a treasure trove for those who love unearthing vintage treasures and unique finds. Whether you’re hunting for a statement piece or a quirky souvenir, the island’s thrift shops offer a vibrant mix of items that tell their own stories.

Vintage Clothing

For fashion enthusiasts, Key West’s thrift shops are a haven of unique clothing. Stores like Second Time Around and Blue Marlin offer racks of vintage apparel, each piece with its own flair. From 70s bohemian dresses to retro Hawaiian shirts, there’s something to suit every style. These shops are perfect for finding that one-of-a-kind item that stands out in any wardrobe.

Antiques and Collectibles

If antiques are your passion, In One Era at the corner of Petronia and Thomas is a must-visit. This shop is renowned for its gorgeous vintage treasures, ranging from neat glassware to historic memorabilia. Each item is carefully curated, ensuring that collectors can find something truly special.

Souvenirs with a Story

For those looking to bring a piece of Key West home, thrift shops offer souvenirs with a story. The Salvation Army Family Store is a great spot to find local mementos at budget-friendly prices. Meanwhile, Happy Island adds a playful twist with its colorful selection of keepsakes. These items not only serve as reminders of your trip but also support sustainable shopping.

Unique Home Décor

Key West’s thrift shops are also a great place to find unique home décor. The Shore Store is particularly known for its coastal-themed items, perfect for bringing a touch of the sea into your home. From nautical trinkets to vintage art pieces, these finds add character and charm to any space.

Exploring thrift shops in Key West FL is like starting on a treasure hunt, where each visit holds the promise of finding something extraordinary. Whether you’re a seasoned thrifter or a curious newcomer, the island’s shops offer a delightful array of vintage gems and unique finds. Next, we’ll share some handy tips for enhancing your thrift shopping experience in Key West.

Thrift Shopping Tips in Key West

Thrift shopping in Key West is a delightful trip filled with surprises, but having a few tips up your sleeve can make the experience even better. Here’s how to get the most out of your thrift shopping trip in this vibrant island paradise.

Bargaining Basics

While not all thrift shops in Key West encourage bargaining, a friendly negotiation can sometimes lead to better deals. Start by asking if prices are negotiable. If they are, be polite and reasonable with your offers. The goal is to strike a fair deal for both parties. Shops like the Salvation Army Family Store might offer some flexibility, especially if you’re buying multiple items.

Scoring the Best Deals

To snag the best deals, timing is everything. Visit shops early in the morning or on weekdays when they’re less crowded. This gives you first dibs on newly stocked items. Keep an eye out for sales or discount days, which are common in places like Second Time Around. Signing up for newsletters or following shops on social media can also alert you to special promotions.

Enhancing Your Shopping Experience

Make the most of your thrift shopping trip by exploring different areas of Key West. Each neighborhood offers its own charm and selection of treasures. For example, The Shore Store is known for its coastal-themed items, while Blue Marlin boasts a fantastic array of vintage clothing.

Take your time browsing through the racks and shelves. The joy of thrift shopping often lies in the unexpected findies. Chatting with store staff can also improve your experience; they might share insights about new arrivals or hidden gems.

Packing Tips for Travelers

If you’re visiting Key West, consider your luggage space before making purchases. Focus on small, lightweight items or plan to ship larger finds back home. This way, you can enjoy your thrift treasures without worrying about packing constraints.

By following these tips, you’ll not only find amazing deals but also enjoy a richer shopping experience. Next, we’ll address some frequently asked questions about thrift shops in Key West.

Frequently Asked Questions about Thrift Shops in Key West


Is Florida good for thrifting?

Absolutely! Florida is a thrift shopping paradise, and Key West is no exception. The Sunshine State is known for its eclectic mix of styles and cultures, which translates into a treasure trove of secondhand finds. From vintage clothing to unique home decor, Florida’s thrift shops offer a wide variety of hidden gems waiting to be finded.

In Key West, the blend of tropical vibes and historic charm improves the thrifting experience. Whether you’re hunting for a quirky souvenir or a piece of vintage jewelry, you’ll likely find something special.

Can you haggle at thrift shops?

Yes, you can often haggle at thrift shops, but it depends on the store. In Key West, some shops are open to bargaining, especially if you’re purchasing several items. It’s all about being polite and respectful. Start by asking if prices are negotiable. If they are, make a fair offer.

For example, at places like the Salvation Army Family Store, staff might be willing to give you a better deal, particularly if you’re buying in bulk or if the item has been in the store for a while. Just remember, the goal is to reach a price that’s fair for both you and the store.

What are the best thrift shops in Key West?

Key West boasts several standout thrift shops that are worth visiting. Here are a few of the best locations:

  • Second Time Around: Known for its wide selection of clothing and household items, this shop is a local favorite for bargain hunters.
  • Salvation Army Family Store: Offers a variety of items, from furniture to clothing, and is a great spot to find discounted treasures.
  • The Shore Store: Perfect for those seeking coastal-themed items and unique souvenirs.
  • Blue Marlin: A must-visit for vintage clothing enthusiasts, offering a fantastic array of retro fashion.
  • Happy Island: Known for its cheerful ambiance and eclectic mix of items, this shop is a joy to explore.


Each of these thrift shops in Key West offers its own unique selection, making the hunt for treasures all the more exciting. Whether you’re a seasoned thrifter or a curious newcomer, Key West’s shops have something for everyone.

Explore these shops to uncover the hidden gems of Key West. Next, we’ll dig into the unique art and shopping experience offered by Handshucked Designs.

Conclusion

Key West is not just a haven for thrift shops; it’s also home to unique art and design experiences that enrich your shopping trip. At the heart of this vibrant scene is Handshucked Designs, where we blend creativity with craftsmanship to offer something truly special.

Our studio in Bahama Village is more than just a store—it’s a celebration of art and design. We specialize in original art, hand-printed apparel, and street art, making each visit an opportunity to find something new and exciting. Our “Lost Cat” series and the whimsical “Hungry Manatee” designs are just a glimpse of the unique creations you’ll find on our shelves.

Visiting Key West offers a diverse shopping experience. You can uncover vintage treasures at local thrift shops and then step into our studio to explore Handshucked Designs. Whether you’re looking for a quirky souvenir or a piece of art that speaks to your soul, Key West has it all.

As you wander through the island’s eclectic mix of shops, Handshucked Designs is here to provide a distinctive piece of Key West to take home. We invite you to explore our studio and find the unique art that defines our beloved island.

Accept the vibrant spirit of Key West through its thrift shops and unique art destinations. Happy hunting!

Stomped Heart
Out Of Stock
Key West Sound Machine
$20.00